Frylock discovers that Shake has trashed the kitchen largely and tells him to go buy things that will help him clean it. When Shake comes back, however, the bag is filled with unrelated items, such as spray cheese. After Meatwad ignites the aerosol can of spray cheese, a creature with well manners comes in from the kitchen and is a creature made from Shake's filth. Meatwad goes off to play dolls with the creature and promptly names him "Ol' Drippy" because he is dripping while they play. Meanwhile, Ol' Drippy goes to get a real doll for Meatwad, but is a cardboard woman in a bikini holding a six pack without a head (Carl had stolen it from a liquor store).
Meanwhile, while Shake takes out all of the filth and dumps it in Carl's pool, Carl comes in to get the so-called "doll" back from Drippy. Drippy kindly gives Carl his Cardboard Standee back and rakes Carl's leaves. Afterwards, Drippy buys coffee for everyone, but there isn't enough for Shake, so he offers Shake his coffee, but Shake just gets angry and knocks it out of Drippy's hand. Shake leaves. When Carl comes over demanding to know why the garbage is in his pool Drippy offers to clean it and the others tell Shake he could learn from Drippy. Shake comes back home in the rain. Shake possibly catches a cold or fever, and Drippy lets him eat his head because it's made of penicillin (But Frylock says "He needs his ass whuppin'!"). Making Meatwad sad watching Shake eat his head, Shake keeps eating his head for three days. After he's done, Drippy is still alive but weakened. Shake goes out to "run amok" and picks up a magazine in the middle of the road up while a large truck is coming. Drippy comes out of the house and pushes Shake out of the way, while the trucks runs over Ol' Drippy. In the pool Frylock and Shake argue while Shake eats wings. After Shakes tells Meatwad Drippy said he didn't like him as he was pushing Shake (a lie) Meatwad asks for a wing which Shake throws. Whe Meatwad finds it he realizes it's only a bone and when he asks where the meat is Shake tells him to "make doll out of that".
- Meatwad names Ol' Drippy because he was dripping; however, he only drips once in the entire episode.
- The grocery bag filled with sand is from "Food Badge".
- Ol' Drippy bought coffee from "Cafe Bean".
- Carl says "If I wanted a wife I'd order one from Russia." Carl later does this in the episode "Mail Order Bride."